Search results

  1. C

    Is commission for IB API orders higher than normal orders?

    Since IB doesn't take PFOF and they're no longer in the market making business, why do they want to discourage the use of directed orders so harshly? at 0.0075 per share it's basically prohibitive.. and in the tiered fee structure I don't see any reason why they would care. Is it so that they...
  2. C

    Historical Imbalance Data for US Equities

    https://www.investopedia.com/terms/n/net-order-imbalance-indicator-noii.asp
  3. C

    how to place an imbalance only orders in TWS?

    Do you have historical data for imbalances? I asked in your other thread along with the helpful info I gave, but you didn't reply
  4. C

    Historical Imbalance Data for US Equities

    Looking for historical data for NOII (Net Order Imbalance Indicator) from Nasdaq TotalView and the analogous data for NYSE. Does anyone know if this data is available somewhere other than buying it direct from exchanges for insanely high prices? I realize this question has been asked multiple...
  5. C

    where can I automatically download realtime Imabalance data?

    Apparently Polygon is supposed to be getting this soon. Do you have historical imbalance data? I am looking for historical.
  6. C

    Question about OPG orders

    As others have said, just use limit orders and don't rely on others to protect you. Pretty simple. However it is not true that there are no protections. IB will price cap OPGs (it's not documented how this works, but I've seen messages in my API logs about orders being capped) and exchanges...
  7. C

    Why ‘Free Trading’ on Robinhood Isn’t Really Free

    I'm with IB and I use the API to trade so all I need to do to reverse is sell 2x the amount of shares I currently have. Whether it takes extra time for borrowing I do not know in practice, I don't do low latency stuff so have never tried to measure this. In theory the time for borrowing is an...
  8. C

    Why ‘Free Trading’ on Robinhood Isn’t Really Free

    Isn't 0.25 the smallest tick on ES? Buy 1 ES @ 2700.25... $135,012.50 Why would ES take less time to execute or SPY not be able to instantly reverse? When you day trade stocks/ETFs on margin there is no interest payment. But now that you mention it, it's true that the futures likely have a...
  9. C

    Why ‘Free Trading’ on Robinhood Isn’t Really Free

    That sounds interesting, so are you saying ES has less slippage? What does slippage mean here and how do you measure it? IIRC and correct me if I'm wrong, SPY typically has a 1c spread during market hours which as a percentage is smaller than 1 tick on ES. If you get price improvement on SPY...
  10. C

    What is the purpose of overfill protection?

    IB does not take any risk. When overfill protection is enabled, they only route one order to the exchange at a time. Clearly this will have a very negative impact on your ability to add liquidity. Source: https://www.interactivebrokers.com/en/index.php?f=617
  11. C

    Will MOC order get filled with uptick?

    If rule 201 is in effect then you need an uptick to get filled, and yes this is true for MOC orders too. I've done thousands of MOCs and 99% of the times that I got no fill, it was due to the circuit breaker. https://www.sec.gov/investor/pubs/regsho.htm
  12. C

    Predicting and executing at the opening price

    Be sure to check the supported exchanges for that order type, it is a very limited set.
  13. C

    Predicting and executing at the opening price

    No. The "Adaptive Algo" can not trade in the auction so is not guaranteed the opening price. The only way to have guaranteed execution at the opening price is to send a Market on Open order to participate in the auction. If you wait until the imbalance data is available it is too late to send...
  14. C

    who can beat IB for US stocks daytrading?

    For the leverage. When I spoke to Rob Friesen (Bright Trading) back in 2014, this is what he told me, straight up. Leverage is the only reason. The prop firm business model is renting capital to undercapitalized traders. This rent is paid in the form of profit split and/or higher commissions...
  15. C

    Does Lightspeed accept Canadian Accounts?

    I do, but it's been years since I was under $25K in my account. I'm 99% sure PDT would still be gone, but you should just confirm it with IB. btw here's the notice they sent out when the change was done: https://www.financialwisdomforum.org/forum/viewtopic.php?t=116368
  16. C

    who can beat IB for US stocks daytrading?

    lower. (lower=cheaper=better): https://www.interactivebrokers.com/en/index.php?f=1595 I believe no one even comes close. Please prove me wrong on that, if you can :)
  17. C

    Does Lightspeed accept Canadian Accounts?

    It is grossly outdated. IB Canada dropped the PDT rule years ago (in 2013, IIRC). Source: I had an IB Canada account when it happened. I would advise the OP to simply phone IB to confirm this.
  18. C

    who can beat IB for US stocks daytrading?

    True DMA could be very important for certain types of HFT-like strategies. With IB, direct routing (through the API) is heavily disincentivized with extra fees. I've not ever traded such strategies, just theorized about them. Another thing to consider here is IB's margin interest rates are much...
  19. C

    Does Lightspeed accept Canadian Accounts?

    PDT does not apply to IB Canada accounts.
  20. C

    Interactive Brokers Fined $5.5 Million for Naked Short Selling Violations

    Lee-, you're right, this isn't what's causing the dip. Most brokers down around 5% in premarket: https://seekingalpha.com/news/3384439-online-brokers-sink-premarket-jpmorgan-unveils-investing-app
Back
Top