Search results

Agreed

Good question. 1. Find and validate trading edge(s). Period. 2. Research and stay in sim until you complete step 1. Period.

Trading small is bullshit. Has nothing to do with nothing. You either know how to make money trading or you do not. Period.

Here is the best advice every one is to scared to say. Don't listen or follow anyone who has no proof of making "real" or "sim" money. Period.

Master Pu, Risk management or money management is just an excuse for not knowing how to make money in trading and not having a trading edge(s). Period. That is just an excuse to keep traders running in circles and take their time and energy. And keep people talking. Risk Management and Money...

Deaddog, My great grandfather use to always say. "Boy, I see better than I hear" I hear you talking, but I still don't see nothing.

deaddog, Please do not mistake me. I am logical thinking person. Binary thinking. I do not know if price action trading makes money. I am not saying it even makes money. What I am saying and what I have proof of, I have never witness someone who trades or even talks about trading price...

If I was a NFL football player. I rather play for a coach that wins the most. That is Bill Belichick. I do not care less on the method he uses to wins. I just want to win and get super bowl ring. The same applies to trading. Why focus on price action, if nobody is winning with it, that I know...

Lol, you are guys are super funny to me. 406 post debating about rather a style of trading has edge for a trader and............: 1. NOT ONE person post their broker account showing price action has edge for them. 2. NOT ONE person post their equity curve showing price action has edge for...

Hello Scataphagos, I am definitely trying in automation PA concepts. I like your confidence when it comes to Price TA. It gives me hope.:)

Hello rb7, I do not know if PA and TA can be automated. Good question

Very good question. Noone makes money in price action trading. There is absolutely zero proof any where on earth of any price action trader making money year to year or even beating the SP500 index return. Zero. None.

Hello Scataphagos, The reason traders invest time and energy in the automated trading system approach and Not Price action or technical analysis approach because their no proof of any day trader or swing trader using price action or technical analysis that makes consistent money. However, the...

Hello LoganSilver, Questions please: 1. Where will the trader obtain realistic goals for trading? 2. Who/what to compare goals to? What if my goals is 3000% return per month? How do I know if 3000% return is achievable? 3. How do I know if there is actual day traders making X%, or XX%, XXXX%...

Hello deaddog, Questions please: 1. Where does a trader obtain a trading plan with proven and validated edge for trading strategy(s)? Thank you,

Hello Scataphagos, This is a very valid point you made sir. Thank you

Hello Scataphagos, I have a question for you as you been trading for awhile, I assume. Just your opinion. For a day trader, what is realistic expected returns year to year? 20%, 60% 1000% or just be happy if you beat the SP500 year to year. Perhaps I need to start new thread on this. Thanks

Hello geth03, Question: If I show you a strategy with an expectancy greater than 0.00 and drawdown of $5000 for XX,XXX prior historical trades and made $50K this past year on NQ futures chart, would you trade it. Please respond with only Yes or No.

wiesman02, I love it!!!

And all that matters is what after this trade, is what?? If you repeat what you stated for every triangle breakout scenario on "large volume" for the next or past XXX to X,XXX trades is the expectancy greater than 0.00 and acceptable drawdown while obtaining expectancy greater than 0.00. If...