What is the best approach for this trade ?

Actually Mr @tommcginnis

I did take your suggestion (most of it :) ) and did buy a call ! But it was not at 2930 as suggested, but at 2950. But the confusing thing is that the call went to 5 bux (gain of 4.4 points) even though ES was ~ 2872 but now with ES at 2882 the call is only 1.70. not sure how that is for this Opt! Delta has increased. Is it because of Theta that this has decreased to $1.70 or so ?

You can exit your 2950 for ~$1.50 right now.
If you insist on staying in, sell the 2955 ASAP.
 
You can exit your 2950 for ~$1.50 right now.
If you insist on staying in, sell the 2955 ASAP.
{chirping crickets...}
Fine, then!
Sell 2x2955
Buy 1x2960
pocket $1.95
RISK FREE.



["And what if the market goes to 2955 tomorrow??" You wish.]
 
Hi @tommcginnis

I do read up and try to understand the market parameters as best as I can. As of now though I am looking for suggestion to best close this trade with min. L. I do not know what sunk cost means - I googled it and the answer does not link to this trade at least in mi understanding (it has more results about propert market)

I do not understand how you say the max L. is $1.35 without adding the $21 on the put and also as said above - Sunk costs - so I am not sure how to read this.

I already closed the call of 2950 as of now (for 1.85 and made 1.12 points) and sold a call for 2945 for abt 2.77 points. Seems like I have abt 14 points on the put to go (not sure exactly how many points because I need to find how to get a list of trades that I have done and the P/L on them in a simple format. IB has very confusing statements and does not have a simple list of trades with P/L on them. Also where does it show P/L on a credit spread 28 Aug that closed OTM). Hence need simple suggestions if possible (i.e. cannot understand some of the jargon as now).

Appreciate your inputs.

Hi @ bon

I understand what leg means in trading. I am looking to understand the full statement abt "not opening up the legs when closing the position". I do not understand if you mean "existing legs should also be closed along with the underlying position" or you mean "should not open new legs when closing the position"

Thank you for your inputs !
 
Last edited:
Hi @tommcginnis

I do read up and try to understand the market parameters as best as I can. As of now though I am looking for suggestion to best close this trade with min. L. I do not know what sunk cost means - I googled it and the answer does not link to this trade at least in mi understanding (it has more results about propert market)

I do not understand how you say the max L. is $1.35 without adding the $21 on the put and also as said above - Sunk costs - so I am not sure how to read this.

I already closed the call of 2950 as of now (for 1.85 and made 1.12 points) and sold a call for 2945 for abt 2.77 points. Seems like I have abt 14 points on the put to go (not sure exactly how many points because I need to find how to get a list of trades that I have done and the P/L on them in a simple format. IB has very confusing statements and does not have a simple list of trades with P/L on them. Also where does it show P/L on a credit spread 28 Aug that closed OTM). Hence need simple suggestions if possible (i.e. cannot understand some of the jargon as now).

Appreciate your inputs.

Hi @ bon

I understand what leg means in trading. I am looking to understand the full statement abt "not opening up the legs when closing the position". I do not understand if you mean "existing legs should also be closed along with the underlying position" or you mean "should not open new legs when closing the position"

Thank you for your inputs !
I keep asking you a simple question about your original position but I don't know why you shy away from disclosing it
One and last time
This is what we know so far
Long to open ES at 2936.30
Bought PUT @strike 2935 for -26.55 point
Soled a Call @ strike? for +XXX? ( yes we know you made 5 point by closing this but what was the original?
You max risk ( call it whatever you like ) = (2936.3-2935) + 26.55
= 1.3 +26.55 = 27.85 Points
Now take the CALL premium away from it =?
Max Upside = Any ? depends on the strike of the soled call
End of story
 
Back
Top