OANDA vs IB

[cooldude]

Quote from TradinWise:

Quote from Remiraz:
So what you're saying here is that nobody knows if Oanda hedges our trade on the interbank or take the opposite side of them. If they hedge our trade, no one knows how much they hedge it for.

However, we should believe that they do hedge just because they say so? :eek:

Do you trade at Oanda?

:eek: :eek: :eek:

 

[Remiraz]

Quote from cooldude:

Do you trade at Oanda?

:eek: :eek: :eek:

:eek: :eek: :eek: :eek:

 

[TradingWise]

Remiraz speaks like he trades at Oanda, is my question really that weird? Maybe he deposited some funds to try them out.

Oanda spreads this morning, look at EUR/USD

 

[Remiraz]

Quote from TradingWise:

Remiraz speaks like he trades at Oanda, is my question really that weird? Maybe he deposited some funds to try them out.

Oanda spreads this morning, look at EUR/USD

Yeah i do trade at the Big O but just a small account. :eek:





Is that a 0.9 pip spread??

How do their liquidity provider profit?? EUR was at 1 pip for a day some time in year 2003, Stumm told us they're working on maintaining that spread. Year 2005 and no 1 pip spread.

I wish there was a bucketshop that openly tell us they take the other side of our orders. By doing this they could openly give us 0 pip spreads heh.

If the Big O can do 0.5 pip spread it'll be great....great for scalping the crap out of them! :eek:

 

[aPismoClam]

OANDA vs IB

battle of the bucket shops?

 

[cooldude]

Quote from Remiraz:

Yeah i do trade at the Big O but just a small account. :eek:





Is that a 0.9 pip spread??

How do their liquidity provider profit?? EUR was at 1 pip for a day some time in year 2003, Stumm told us they're working on maintaining that spread. Year 2005 and no 1 pip spread.

I wish there was a bucketshop that openly tell us they take the other side of our orders. By doing this they could openly give us 0 pip spreads heh.

If the Big O can do 0.5 pip spread it'll be great....great for scalping the crap out of them! :eek:

Yeah, he trades at Oanda and it is his right to want to know how Oanda deals with all the accounts.

Maybe when his account becomes a '7 figures' he will switch to Saxo/... and since 'we all know' how Saxo/... work (do we really?) he has no more questions. He will then come to tell us how great Saxo,... are.

Unfortunately you can't trade at Saxo/... (supposedly non bucketshops) like you can at Oanda. (1 Unit).

Also, Oanda loves you trying to 'scalp the crap out of them' because Oanda's Stumm says that scalping is a losing tactic. He can tell you this because he 'knows' that you won't listen!


Mind you, we never listen. But we know how to blame when we lose! Since we lose more than we profit, we blame most of the time, in fact, we are especialized masters in blaming.
:eek:

 

[Remiraz]

Quote from cooldude:

Yeah, he trades at Oanda and it is his right to want to know how Oanda deals with all the accounts.

Maybe when his account becomes a '7 figures' he will switch to Saxo/... and since 'we all know' how Saxo/... work (do we really?) he has no more questions. He will then come to tell us how great Saxo,... are.

Unfortunately you can't trade at Saxo/... (supposedly non bucketshops) like you can at Oanda. (1 Unit).

Also, Oanda loves you trying to 'scalp the crap out of them' because Oanda's Stumm says that scalping is a losing tactic. He can tell you this because he 'knows' that you won't listen!


Mind you, we never listen. But we know how to blame when we lose! Since we lose more than we profit, we blame most of the time, in fact, we are especialized masters in blaming.
:eek:

Saxo is non bucketshop?? :eek:

Scalping might be a losing tactic...but it depends on your definition of scalping. If i scalp with trendfollowing tools and 50 ticks profit target is it then a losing tactic?

If Stumm knows so much about trading why is he running an fx shop instead of trading?

scalping is done by winners. I meant american indian combat winners who scalp their enemies.