Mark Minervini he is legit or not?

I have to agree that anyone can show how to trade on the left hand side of the chart.

As for filtering for earnings beats don't you get the same results by filtering for volume spikes?
Who is doing the buying after an earnings beat which causes a volume spike? I'm assumimg it is the institutions but maybe not as their research should have shown that an earnings beat would happen. Is it just us retailers causing the increase in volume?
There are multiple reasons for volume spikes and you can classify them broadly into two buckets: informed volume vs. liquidity driven volume.

Informed volume is price sensitive and happens when you buy and sell because of new information about the stock or market. E.g. the company is doing much better than you expected or vice versa. Earnings events drive informed volume. Company specific events (or market events like FOMC) also drive informed volume.

Liquidity driven volume is not price sensitive and happens when you buy and sell for cash or to use cash. For example, every time you get your payroll and a % goes into the market, there is incremental buying/selling. Rebalancing activities, option positioning, and time-of-the-year effects (seasonality) explain those.

So using a volume filter is not helpful because you still need to classify what type of volume is occurring.

The who is buying part... most professionals think that the marginal buyer of stocks are long only investors like wealth managers and mutual fund managers. Since those types of investors aren't focused on predicting quarterly earnings, and prefer to take a longer term view, they will be the biggest incremental buyer or seller. Hedge funds and other speculators are buying before (and also after depending on the results).
 
%%
Legit?? Frankly I got more out of Michael Marcus , Mike Masters, Mark Weinstein, LBR, IBD Founding Father+ Dave Ramsey .
FFTY seldom beats SPY benchmark, but I still got+ get plenty out of IBD-ETFs + their newspaper.
Some may hold it against him, but I like the way M Marcus admitted he lost money in all his CA real estate except one property.:caution::caution:
 
I would say that in my opinion Minervini is not a scam and is a good trader but there is no doubt in my mind that he makes ALOT more money and greater returns running a stock market information/education/seminar
business than he does trading

selling the “trading dream” thru books, monthly subscriptions, expensive seminars, and other various services is his real cash cow in my opinion
—not trading
 
Back
Top