Is this a good risk management strategy?

Seems to me that you haven't expressed yourself well and some others have misinterpreted your meaning. You've said that you place a trailing stop, so therefore you do take profit if price moves in your favor and the trailing stop moves beyond your entry price. Are you attempting to automate yor trading using such a strategy?
Exactly, I thought I made it clear enough, but I guess not. I just started using stop losses as a means to manage risk. Before I would enter a trade with no plan, hoping I would exit when situations were favorable for me. I realized taking a loss in trading is harder when you're actually watching it. I'm disciplined, but only when I use a stop loss taking losses or profit is a lot harder than I thought. Stop losses seem to eliminate the indecision for me. I've literally waited waited for a stock to lose 20 percent plus before I exited the trade ....painful lesson learned.
 
Sorry about the confusion, I meant I'd only exit and take a profit if my stock was to rise and fall back down to my "trailing" stop loss. I want to let my winners run so to speak.

For example I enter a trade and place a 5% trailing stop, stock could either immediately go down and I exit with 5% loss or stock rises 15% then loses 5% on a downswing I profit 10% and exit the trade.
Ok, that seems reasonable.
 
When I enter a trade I immediately place a trailing stop at a certain percentage based on the volatility of the stock (higher volatility larger trailing stop). If it hits my stop I'm out, if my trade goes good I let my winners run. I never take a profit; I only exit my trade when the stock hits the stop loss.

Well, trailing stops make sense when you get already a big winner, you are near your target, but not sure if it could reverse or continue to make new highs.
For example, you can sell half and keep the other half with a trailing stop. It could give you an extra bonus.
But placing trailing stops at the start ? Nope, because you will not manage carefully your entry point. You must be confident about your timing, not about your protections.
You need to be 100% focused before you enter and minutes/hours following your entry point.
Good trades work well and fast. You can still get out fast if you were wrong.

CM
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bry
But placing trailing stops at the start ? Nope, because you will not manage carefully your entry point.


Why do you imagine that entering a position with a trailing stop, rather than with any other kind of stop, implies that you wouldn't be managing your entry-point carefully? :rolleyes:


You must be confident about your timing, not about your protections.


"It must be true: I read it at EliteTrader". :mad:
 
Why do you imagine that entering a position with a trailing stop, rather than with any other kind of stop, implies that you wouldn't be managing your entry-point carefully? :rolleyes:
Trailing stop or any kind of physical stops : at the start, you feed traders that chase stops.
Better wait best entry, no stops, and get out if your mental stop is reached.
When your trade is a winning one, nobody chases your stops. Money is already in your pocket.

"It must be true: I read it at EliteTrader". :mad:
Yes, this is my truth. Tell me yours?

CM
 
Long-term successful trading is about risk management, not about highest win-rates.
Seriously? Is this it?
You think risk-management is the most important.
Nope. If that was true, all risk-managers would be rich. All quants would be rich.
LT successful trading is about skills.
You develop them with experience, testing good and bad methods, set ups ...
And finally find one that fits your own personality and history.

I agree with you, this is not about highest win-rates. I never said that. Some people got a 30% win rate and still win.
But if you consider your entry point is not key, you are not a trader : you are at best an investor, at worst a loser.

CM
 
When I enter a trade I immediately place a trailing stop at a certain percentage based on the volatility of the stock (higher volatility larger trailing stop). If it hits my stop I'm out, if my trade goes good I let my winners run. I never take a profit; I only exit my trade when the stock hits the stop loss.
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
Good bull market plan,[ETF or basket of stocks] never take a profit;
try that in a bear market,single stocks, you're a dead duck.You need a selling plan;average age of people is 77/+ years old; get a selling plan.

Wisdom is profitable to direct-merry Christmas-happy hanukkah.
 
Back
Top