IRONY: Metatrader4 forgot to shred this document..evidence of scam

Quote from Rorschach_test:

Hi Jason,thank you for your reply.

Any successful,consistent traders at FXCM,with the Dealing Desk option ,that you can confirm?

Thank you

I guess not.
 
Quote from jago25_98:

One thing though. FXCM's micro account has future lot sizes that are way too big for me personally, whether that's any contract. Can you recommend a broker that allows to bet smaller lots?

Hi Jago,

FXCM is looking into offering smaller lot sizes on our CFDs for oil, metals and stock indices. While I don't have specific dates for you yet, I'll post more details when I have them in our discussion thread: http://www.elitetrader.com/vb/showthread.php?s=&postid=3897726#post3897726

Jason
 
Quote from Jason Rogers:

Hi RT,

Sorry for not replying sooner, but I just noticed your post. Yes, FXCM has clients trading successfully on both DD and NDD. The table in my previous post comparing both options can help you determine which execution offering is best for you: http://www.elitetrader.com/vb/showthread.php?s=&postid=3900030#post3900030

Hi Jason,can you please provide with some more specifics about how DD works?Please,bear with me.I mean,there are a lot of FX brokers.How does it look like technically?Many people complain,that with some brokers,the money even doesn`t go into the interbank market,even though you see on your platform that your connected to the ''real live account''.Is that sort of manipulation possible?If so,how do i control it?Also,how do find out if the brokes is DD,if it doesn`t reveal?

thanks!
 
Quote from Rorschach_test:

Hi Jason,can you please provide with some more specifics about how DD works?Please,bear with me.I mean,there are a lot of FX brokers.How does it look like technically?Many people complain,that with some brokers,the money even doesn`t go into the interbank market,even though you see on your platform that your connected to the ''real live account''.Is that sort of manipulation possible?If so,how do i control it?Also,how do find out if the brokes is DD,if it doesn`t reveal?

thanks!

A broker that uses DD execution may actively be taking a position in the market, which exposes the firm to market risk. When you are long, the DD broker may be short. When you are short, the DD broker may be long. So your losses can equate to the DD broker's profit. Alternatively, your profits can equate to the DD broker's loss. Certain strategies expose DD brokers to more risk, such as automated strategies or strategies that trade at a high frequency.

To better manage their market risk, some DD brokers actively intervene in their clients' trading by re-quoting orders. Re-quotes are when a DD broker rejects your order and instead quotes you a worse price. They do this to avoid taking loss on the other side of your trade if the market moves in your favor. If a broker re-quotes you, that's a sign they are operating a dealing desk.

There are no re-quotes at FXCM even though we offer both DD and NDD execution. That's because if you are trading on our DD execution and your trading style exposes us to more risk than we're comfortable with, we may change your execution type to NDD. This is how FXCM can comfortably offer both options without having to resort to re-quoting our clients as can occur with other brokers on their DD execution.
 
The funny thing is, i was evaluating this metatrader platform and it was during a fed realease, i saw price drop over 25 points extra on the mt platform, so i quickly tunred to my other qoute feed and seen that it never went near there, then checked my brokerage account and my trade was still in, since i would have been stopped out by that extra spike. Therefore i didn't take the software seriously.

I feel sorry for the guys getting screwed by this.......regarding my trade, it was on nzd and it ended up being profitable, if i was trading through these guys, i would have had a loss and a lossed profit opportunity.

A good trader can take advantage of the spike (latency) and enter.
 
as many others and i've been crying about staying away from mt4 broker for any live trading, many didn't listen.

heres more evidence implicating mt4 as a complete scam job.

i hope you guys enjoy.

credits to qtmspin @ FF i wonder where he got the doc.

more here.

http://www.forexfactory.com/showthread.php?t=70582
MT4 is as far as I can tell fine for the retail trader. The one HUGE problem with it is that you have to exit all your positions in a symbol in a stop loss or stop gain. There is no scaling in or out which is problematical. If they fixed that, it would be perfectly usable.
 
Back
Top