Search results

No argument at all. It is then a question of one finding 'where' it is one prefers to trade in the sense of which time frame. I like 15 min ES. Others will choose something else. One of course can use the time frames above and below the 'trading' time frame as aids.

In truth I have no idea what point you are trying to make but if you can make money with said point then please do. I'm not trying to be a smartass it's just that it's clear to me we look at the market differently. I'm talking about trend lines - pure and simple.

This has the potential of being a very good thread providing we do not, as the saying goes, "venture too far down the rabbit-hole". So let me move things up a few levels and suggest that there are things one sees with DOM that one doesn't see with non-DOM, where DOM refers to the dominant trend...

This thread was left dangling. One need not get into the 1-2-3 thingy to get better control of what one is doing. I will only say that it does indicate that before one gets a reversal there must first be a retrace. So a few more points re the RTL (right trend line) which is what most people...

Is this a rhetorical question? What's on the other side of a 50 car order? Why big green, naturellement.

TS data is raw data so there is really no such thing as 'raw' TS data. When, as Jack used to call them, the big green crew on the sidelines, steps in at the market, the book either stands or falls.

Much simpler to just watch the wall in real time - it either stands or falls. In this instance "...meant what he said ..." simply refers to Jack using the T&S in a particular way. If you'll recollect, the post began with a reference to his manner of speaking. More generally, he was a firm...

Mandelbrot was not the first to see the market waves but he gave the whole wave thing a touch of class. Using a simple up/down/up generator and rotating it from +90 degrees to something < -90 degrees to give a down up down generator (Mandelbrot did not use this method) you can generate the...

It is a given that the market is either trending or it isn't trending. Consolidation is a more general expression of A and D. So we need to move on from the obvious. One question to be answered is when is Distribution going to end and the downtrend begin and similarly when is Accumulation...

Oh WTF - it's almost Hallowe'en. The word is the number "3". If you look at his fractal generator you will see how he envisaged this 3 thingy.

To say that Jack could be a bit on the cryptic side would be an understatement. What he's talking about with the YM reference, IMO, is that if YM showed anything but a completed 3rd leg, then one should hold. The T&S stuff is beyond my ken but I have no doubt that Jack meant what he said. In...

IMO, the only true trendline is the Sperandeo trend line. It is what the smart money uses. Trendlines have influence/are felt over multiple time frames and highly correlated (r2 > 0.95) instruments. That said, if you wish to use some other TL protocol, please do.

Here is a trace from a few days ago during and after rollover. It serves to illustrate the utility of a TL. I draw channels but you don't have to. The start of the downtrend is in the early AM of 9/8. One can, in real time draw left to right TL's and basically just sit until price bumps into...

Taleb's books were great. He is a must read for anyone serious about the markets. It would spoil the fun if I told you but what is there is worth the search. Fractality certainly sums up the book but then that's not surprising. This finding surprised Mandelbrot.

And also with you. When the logic which drives your anticipation is Boolean, there is only one possibility. But it can be (and has been) a sonamabitch to achieve that Boolean state. Benoit Mandelbrot authored a great book called "The Misbehavior of Markets". IMO, there is a single word...

Agreed. Nice read. Prediction - no. Anticipation - yes. Anticipation requires attention because you do not know when 'it' is going to happen, you just know that it is going to happen. As in, for example, anticipating the break of a RTL and preparing for a reversal. Whatever your...

Merci. C'est vrais.

Tx ST. Interestingly Sperandeo and DeMark were/are contemporaries. The former (born in 1945) first published in 1991, the latter (born in 1947) in 1994. A Sperandeo TL is drawn left to right whereas the DeMark method does it right to left. I prefer the former since the TL can be extended...

My error, FWIW, I use 10 charts with RTH, formerly the former and 8 charts with ETH, formerly the latter. A right trendline (RTL) is the right side of a channel and this is all that many people draw. If one adds a left trendline (LTL) then one generates channel. IMO, a channel is much more...

Believe I said I trade a 900 second chart and use a 300 second chart as an indicator. The reason for using seconds vs minutes is that with my charting software, which is Ninja Trader, if you use seconds for ETH and minutes for RTH then you can have both ETH and RTH in the same workspace...