Search results

This raises an important issue.. We all at one time said it was acceptable for a Justice to not comment on how they would decide a case if it came before them. Now we are talking about Justice candidates that are telling Senators in private chambers what they would do on a case if it came...

The Court made a clear distinction of the abortion issue and marriage. There is no SC that could ever find justification to overturn Loving or Oberfeld and DOBBS specifically mentions them by name as falling under the right to privacy and protected. The Roe decision always had major issues...

yeah Doe had a whole series of hoops and a committee and a doctor and then you had to demonstrate proof of medical reasons. Also GA limited abortions to residents of the State only. Roe wiped out all of those but it was way more restrictive than TX I think.

Kamala may be stretching it a bit because the right to privacy is guaranteed by the Constitution, the right to an abortion is not according to the Dobbs decision as written. That is all they tried to say. Abortion, according to DOBBS is a competing decision between the woman and the State on...

The right to privacy in a marriage came from a few cases collectively such as Griswold; Loving; and Lawrence cases. Since Roe was not about marriage it simply tried to expand the discussion in Griswold to include abortion. Doe was regarding GA statutes on abortion that required a physician...

Dobbs does not outlaw abortion so abortions will continue in the U.S. despite your objections to it...so the SC does not call it murder.

are the two ETFs perfectly correlated?

c'mon GWB... you threw him a softball...

most people who vote in the U.S. are not that smart....

I have not done the research but are there abortion bans right now in state constitutions? I dont think so since it is hard ot amend a constitution. I think it will still be via hte legislature.

Thet issue is whether a majorly controlled Congress by the Dems can do something to address abortion is really cloudy. I dont know if they can take, for example, Roe's criteria and use it to legislate legal and improper abortions but then where does that control? Maybe in federal hospitals...

The court dodged a bullet here not addressing the issue of 100% ban. They did accept implicitly the idea a state can balance the mother's rights and the state's right to protect the unborn and thus a 15 week period like in MISS would be reasonable. The made an issue to say any State's laws...

Sorry where a state does NOT allow abortions 100%

Ugh Joe.... the decision specifically claims this decision is limited to the abortion discussion and all the other rights and cases used in conjunction with Roe are spearated out as completely different. dems are not going to get any traction on this if they resort to hyperbole to scare voters...

who has been the most prominent in pushing their religious agenda into U.S. politics? Christian fundamentalists and conservative christians...

I never said it was only a religious issue: "This is a very legal issue but the defining line is clouded by religion and different moral beliefs" - Ocho you just latched on to the religion part

No one cares about my personal beliefs on religion and it is getting a little creepy that you seem to care so much either. I dont fucking know you..... You asked me if there are Christians who deem it murder and that is what drives their political message on abortion and I showed it to you. I...

Pope: Abortion is murder https://www.vaticannews.va/en/pope/news/2021-09/pope-abortion-is-murder-the-church-must-be-compassionate.html If you dont feel like reading what the right Christians have said I cannot do your research for you.

are you denying the religious right opposes all forms of abortions because they deem it murder? You cannot simply ignore that argument just because you dont like it, that has been the religious right's MO from the beginning of the abortion debate.

Dobbs draft says the following: "The Constitution does not prohibit the citizens of each State from regulating or prohibiting abortion. Roe and Casey arrogated that authority. We now overrule those decisions and return that authority to the people and their elected representatives." So the...