Search results

:D why? i am having so much fun. everybody is posting here. why should i post anything? why are you asking me ? Ask them ! to post their trades [here].

:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D you should have told me 20 years ago this is what Brooks meant, i would have at least enjoyed my self....i am almost an alcoholic now but it would have been better than being a traderlic:D:D

in hindsight it is easy :D

like you said but that means that is not the norm. sometimes you can trade well, like just now Es is trading, I am trading, albeit in sim but i am finding it is ok. i want to hone my skills as it were without having the money dagger over my head. welcome! first time i noticed you here in ET

i think Frederick made it clear that he did! [move on] he is just helping us or others, who are on the fence, to decide about Brooks. fair enough. this forum is meant for just that so all kudos to him and to you ,schizo, for spreading light on the issue. As Goethe said 'where there is much...

what is the meaning of price action? it means everything is in the price and everything that we need to know is in the price. it is in front of us. to be read like a book or newspaper-digital of course[:D]. now i agree with Brooks that every bar has a reason to be there but why it is there...

wow i agree with one hundred percent maybe a thousand. as i said in my post no 126 and i quote " i have also believed, contrary to popular belief, that there are no secrets in markets and that if someone claims to have found the secret formular, for making millions by trading, it is rubbish...

Aloha? wow that is why i come here to meet people i would not meet anywhere else. and yes i too noticed that attraction my posts have and is that not the main reason i am posting ? so that everyone benefits from healthy discussion. i have also believed, contrary to popular belief, that there...

:D:D:D:D yes i agree with you there. but at the same time, he does offer some logic why prices move as they do. for eg a break of the bear trend line followed by test of the low/high accompanied with a good reversal bar is a fantastic reason to take a trade. now i do not need a whole 3...

that is exactly what i said maybe in slightly different words

my wins were fluke and my losses were just a result of misunderstanding. i have a very contrary belief that all market movements are the results of traders logically buying and selling. brooks tries to explain why he thinks it is so too.. i continue to hold that belief.

thks but it is not a knowledge problem /issue. it is an application problem. also trading globex in asian session though last week it gave good trades-usually it is not liquid. so i have more or less decided not trade asian session except by using practice/sim

thanks for dropping in it is reassuring that there are good traders here and in the world. it will inspire me

i have done it. i traded forex live with real money for 10 years and lost 200000usd and accounts to prove it so i know you are right

i wish i could chain you here but i will let you go because trading is more important. this forum needs YOU

wow this thread is attracting a lot of accomplished and experienced traders with powers to express ideas clearly and succinctly with the least noise. overnight does the same thing but more colorfully. i just realize that trading live you are not thinking about the trade or technical isuues -i am...

sorry the trades in my latest journal are for real money

the trades is this thread are for real money that i can withdraw

probably is because saying Brooks is a fraud is saying technical analysis is a fraud. maybe it who knows. like you said comic hour

that is what i am saying. Brooks is not Brooks. i have stuck to technical analysis. not Brooks. he is teaching technical analysis and if trading is as easy as learning something, everyone would have excelled at it. there is a lot of emotion with money and making and losing it.You can blame...