Search results

  1. A

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    Thanks for the comments and chart txuk. I don't have a way to identify hips/ditches/stalls yet, so I've added that to my list of research items. I can't believe I just pulled a Spoonerism on ET. LOL
  2. A

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    Just a couple of comments from my perspective on this. A FTT can only occur after a channel has developed. A channel can only occur after a point three has been identified. A channel has a pt 1, a pt 2, and at the most two pt 3s. The channel may be widened to accomodate a large volume bar...
  3. A

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    FTT means "Failure To Traverse." It is an indication that a trend has ended and a new one has begun. FTT sequence: A channel has formed (i.e. pts 1,2,3 are defined) Price has visited the RTL, and is in the process of traversing to the LTL (i.e. R2L traverse) FTT occurs when: Price does...
  4. A

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    Sorry guys I'm still not seeing what you mean :( If I pull out so I can see a couple of days back, I do see that we are in a ST long trend. However, within the context of the channel I drew, the two arrows point to bars where, as I understand it, FTT's have occurred. I understand a FTT...
  5. A

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    I was going over the charts today and drawing in the channels and came across this. I've seen this before, and to be honest, it drives me nuts. It's a FTT that did not become a point 1. Is it a FTT? Is it a FFTT? Is it something else? Right now I have it classified as a "What The Frell?"...
  6. A

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    Hi Stalker - Thanks for the suggestions. When I first started looking at PRV, I tried to get a 30 second chart up with Ensign. No go - the lowest granularity based on time is 1 minute. My intention is to build a PRV tool (as txuk as suggested.) I'm a software engineer, so I can leverage...
  7. A

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    Hi Dan, Sure thing, see the attached sheet. The colored dots you see are the volume that showed up at the given times. I use several colors so that I don't have to print out a sheet for each bar. I don't remember what time this was done at, so I don't have a reference for you to compare to -...
  8. A

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    Interesting that you brought that up - many times I was running my PRV sheet and wondering "What are they doing?!" My sheets look like my 2 year olds "drawings." I just couldn't get a good feel for the volume moves - it was really staccato. It seemed like there were lots of intrabar bursts of...
  9. A

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    As an explanatory note - When I feel I have a point one, I use Ensigns parallel line tool to draw the trend line, and this comes up as the baby-blue channel. I make the tentative channel width based on the point 1 bar ends. On the second bar, I modify the trend line slope to match. When I...
  10. A

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    Midday to EOD. One thing I am trying to overcome is redrawing channels to fit after the fact. Usually I would do that in order to "clean it up" so these are pretty messy. Anthony
  11. A

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    Chart up to midday-ish
  12. A

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    Here is some further excellent feedback I received from Icarus in a pm. At his encouragement, I'm posting it here.
  13. A

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    "Pardon my friend; he's a little slow" Llyod Christmas, Dumb and Dumber I'll preface this post with the statement that I was very stupid today. I should not have taken one trade until I had at least come up with an exit sequence. Why? I guess I thought I could continue doing what I had been...
  14. A

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    I originally thought it was just his humor. The more I think about it though, he is also saying that he pulls the trigger ("hair trigger") when the market says to go. Could be wrong. Been known to happen before :)
  15. A

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    Thanks much! On first pass I think I see a lot of predicting that I did. Another issue to address. On a side note, my comment about "wanting to be a hairy trader" was a bit of Hershey Humor. See...
  16. A

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    I have struggled for what seems like an eternity to get something, anything, that works (for me) consistently. Many times I have questioned whether I should be pursuing a path as a trader or not. Your comments here have encouraged me immensely - thank you! I had a bit of difficulty with this...
  17. A

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    Chart.
  18. A

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    I took 2 trades today. I didn't get up until 9:45, so I missed the opening and hence didn't take any AM trades. I had originally intended to just follow the market and practice the drills, but I couldn't resist the PM breakout trade. S1 @ 14:31 1294.75 exit @ 15:31 1294.5 +.25 Entered on...
  19. A

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    I can't speak for Jack, but I honestly don't think he would have suggested you do the PRV drills with the expectation that you know those things. I took a 30 second timer, printed out a stack of the sheets I posted, and went to town. Start at the bottom row. Every 30 seconds, record on...
  20. A

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    But not this time, and not in this thread. Your question really is better addressed in Spyder's journal, or by starting a new thread.
Back
Top