Search results

  1. F

    Channels

    I don't recall that you mentioned this many years ago. But if some people knew that already at that time it would have saved some confusion. Because I think many people assumed from your writings that there are ONLY complete channels but then got stuck because they discovered that in reality...
  2. F

    jack hershey and others..

    I think Jack could maybe live with the first few lines of this whole list but the further you go down this list the less it becomes compatible with the way Jack trades. The list was created by CW traders for other CW traders. A SCT trader doesn't need all of this and knows it is wrong. Using...
  3. F

    hmm.no edges in the markets

    You know this but yet you are obsessed by him. In numerous posts you are following/stalking him. Trying to convince him, trying to teach him, trying to convert him. What is this fixation!? What are you trying to achieve?
  4. F

    hmm.no edges in the markets

    Because Jack's reply was deleted... here is what he replied: There is a high potential that what you wrote is incorrect and there is a rumour that you probably tried to steal the "Cash cow". :p :D
  5. F

    I am getting my butt handed to me on a daily basis!

    I wish Jack would have intervened long time ago when everybody was using the approach you describe. At one point everybody who tried to understand that approach (trying to fit "The Pattern" to the bars on their screen) automatcally ended at sitations where things didn't seem to fit. WTF!? It...
  6. F

    I am getting my butt handed to me on a daily basis!

    sorry, found the answer above.
  7. F

    I am getting my butt handed to me on a daily basis!

    Thanks! I will try to process what you wrote. I am currently wondering what in your world/mind/system the words "failsafe" and "routine" mean. There must be a reason why you divided the four trend tables in those two parts. Let me invent something roughly: If you have no clue what you are...
  8. F

    I am getting my butt handed to me on a daily basis!

    This is what I'm currently struggling with: 1. Let's say I identify an event at n as = PP3 and n-1 = Ab. I now see that I can find this in two locations in the 8 Modrian panels. I could either have a Set A (green) or a Set D (purple) type of trend. How do I know which one to choose? If I look...
  9. F

    I am getting my butt handed to me on a daily basis!

    TN can not degap intrabar. Even the algorithm that draws the boxes is too dumb to identify intrabar gaps and draw the boxes correctly. Therefore you have to do it mentally and put a note in your log. The three bars you highlighted are not a lateral because the second bar had a gap and after...
  10. F

    I am getting my butt handed to me on a daily basis!

    No! There is no "nearly"!!!! Every case can be CLEARLY defined mathematically. Scroll up and see how Jack explains the Hitch to Jerred. What is the definition for a FTP? Do the highs of the two bars have to be equal? Or similar" Or nearly? Or slightly? What about lows? Look at the drawings of...
  11. F

    I am getting my butt handed to me on a daily basis!

    If both h and l are higher (little or much) then it is a XB BUT only if the previous close and the current open are equal. Looking at your image from left to right, top to bottom this is what I would say: All top three = XB Bottom: First is a Sym because the lows are not equal. Even if...
  12. F

    I am getting my butt handed to me on a daily basis!

    Yes. But forget about support and resistance. We need to identify price formations. What formation (10 price cases) does the new bar create in relation to the previous bar(s). Can you find and post a real chart which contains a lateral? A lateral = 3 or more bars still in the shadow of bar 1...
  13. F

    I am getting my butt handed to me on a daily basis!

    Sorry... for bar 80 I meant: PP5 or PP5a. And bar 81 I would assign WAIT because price doesn't give permission to measure. On bar 6 I also had a PP6 as a possible assignment but because I placed a RTL from bar 1 to bar 2 then bar 5 looked like a nice BO/T1 and decided to label it a P1 instead.
  14. F

    I am getting my butt handed to me on a daily basis!

    The same seems to be true for bar 53 which has something asigned although it is an internal.
  15. F

    I am getting my butt handed to me on a daily basis!

    Do you know what you need to look for to determine a good starting point? Maybe a Lateral? A FTP? A P1? A T2P? An EE? A BM/Rev? A BO/T1? etc.?
  16. F

    I am getting my butt handed to me on a daily basis!

    OK... I started to look into it myself. The first question somebody would probably have because they didn't annotate the previous day is: Where do I start (on which bar)? How far back do I need to go as a preparation for the next day? What about starting with bar 74? Or bar 78? Why are...
  17. F

    I am getting my butt handed to me on a daily basis!

    I posted the first bars with what the possible assignments could be. They were wrong but Jack corrected it. Could somebody else please try the next few bars of July 7th? Or try the last few bars of friday as a preparation for monday? Yes, I'm lazy, busy, stupid, whatever you want and have...
  18. F

    I am getting my butt handed to me on a daily basis!

    More wordy explanations of ALL eleven elements are scattered in several threads. For now all the "Not" and "Not Not" are not important so the definition you have in the table gives you evrything in short form what the wordy explanations would tell you.
  19. F

    I am getting my butt handed to me on a daily basis!

    That is why I insisted that baro-san was only partly right. Just because it looks like a through doesn't mean we assign one to it. You need to pay attention to the order of events. The table you posted and th evolume test procedure seem very simple. You start with a P1 then check for a...
Back
Top