Search results

  1. E

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    Easy, I am surely not the likes of MAK or Jack but anyhow here is my chart and trades for 05/19 Take a look and feel free to comment and critique. Regards, EX
  2. E

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    “To sense and comprehend after action is not worthy of being called comprehension. To accomplish after striving is not worthy of being called accomplishment. To know after seeing is not worthy of being called knowing. These three are far from the way of sensing and response. Indeed to be...
  3. E

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    The glossary does exist but you may find that you will learn more by creating your own. Everything is as you suggest, all over the place. I might suggest that you begin with topics that you think you know about and cover those first, as you might gain some new ideas as you review them. You...
  4. E

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    IF1- if you go past the close of the prior bar Against the trade then apply IF 2. IF2- if you go past the bottom of the prior bar then reverse. The above link should assist in gaining a better understanding of these applications, along with APA. HTH EX
  5. E

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    You can see from MAK’s post that experience and knowledge are what’s needed to add to something. Asking the questions allows you to see what your looking for, finding it is another thing entirely. No one can really give you the answer, it is something you have to discover. Debriefing as you...
  6. E

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    IB by EOW
  7. E

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    I SEE... thanks
  8. E

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    Easy, did you exit on peaking volume, or some time after? I often find my exits on peaking volume are premature, but im not complaining after all those were some nice apples. Just curious if you notice the same thing or are you using Stoch for exits? Here is the 15m chart
  9. E

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    If two planes were attached with a bungee cord….. one flying directly above the other. The plane on top (ym) increases its altitude eventually the elasticity in the cord would reach a maximum and the lower plane (es) would be pulled up towards the higher plane. (stretch) For squeeze, use...
  10. E

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    MAK! thanks so much for the reply, I can say that I agree 100% with your comments. My intention was not to suggest that trading pictures should be interpreted with subjectivity, but that the emotions each person has play a part in how we observe. Your tools, and comments help tremendously in...
  11. E

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    The unique thing about pictures is that they are subject to interpretation, no one see’s exactly the same picture. Monet painted several iterations of each scene, using different shades to capture different feelings, were they really even the same picture? Each one captured a differing...
  12. E

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    Periodicity?..... Any thoughts on linking the periodicity of cycles in a day to the PRV sheet. As the days unfold, the time to run a complete cycle can be seen and used to anticipate an approximate time of next DU and peaking volume, so if applied to the excel document the expected time should...
  13. E

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    Great observations, 10 years for me, seems like yesterday, I can still hear the grumbling voice of our HEAVY. I believe it is called BASIC for those very reasons you mention. (KISS) I was older than most of my platoon, so my perspective was slightly different than many of the other recruits. It...
  14. E

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    We were all beginners too... Some insights from a beginner too….. First your channels are drawn as you see them appear, that is what is important. As suggested by others drawing plenty of them on each fractal will allow you to glean more and more, I could not agree more with this...
  15. E

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    Here's the file on Rockets
  16. E

    Full-time trader

    PV or present value of future needs. Estimate your needs through life and say someone were to end up with 500k as the amount they need, you do not need 500k today to have it in the future. So what can you realistically make on a consistent basis in the market 30%/yr, 100%/yr whatever you can do...
  17. E

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    Stalker, I think many of us will benefit from what you intend to do with charts etc. I KNOW I don’t know a lot of things, and as you say it is the finer things that you catch subtly when reading the posts here. But the ability to admit lack of understanding is difficult to overcome on a...
  18. E

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    Icarus and nkhoi , I believe Jack once said somewhere “time is the only currency with finite limits and to be sure to spend it wisely” I would like to personally thank both of you, and everyone involved for sharing their time with all those taking on this endeavor. It is great to see...
  19. E

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    Could someone elaborate on their view of sequencing signals with regard to Indicators. I am not clear on what Jack defines as sequences of signals. (coarse sweep - indicators) I am thinking that they should cycle through with price and volume but maybe this is not what is meant by the...
  20. E

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    The Score is a binary method to determine where in the cycle you are. Yes it is the P V A/D relationship you are right. step 1. For each, P V and A/D determine whether it is increasing or decreasing. step 2. for increasing put a 1 in the corresponding box, or for decreasing put a 0 in...
Back
Top