Search results

Nope. See my last post for my current thoughts on that... until I am convinced otherwise:).

Very thought provoking discussion. I don’t think BBT2 could be formed by a simple translation on 11-12 since it does not have the complexity of BB1. Perhaps the inter bar changes on bar 7 provide the rest of the explanation.

No question in my mind that baro-san has corrected the gaussians and trend lines in that snippet.

Tape 2 was/is very confusing and I think I might draw it a little differently now. At bar 9 FC3 upgrades to BBT1. At bar 19 BBT1 upgrades to tape 2 by virtue of the implied ibv because the FC3 gets BO by the OB. Tape 2 now has complexity equal to tape 1 so we qualify for P3 of a traverse...

I can easily understand reluctance to expend currency, mental or otherwise without some sort of proof of benefits. I am the same way. But I trust my own experience to provide sufficient evidence when no empirical proof is forthcoming.

I always regretted not having met Spyder. What a task he committed to when he promised Jack to be his "translator". As it turns out, for me at least, he needed his own translator.

I've spent a heluva lot more than 3 hours trying to understand what he was talking about.

I, like you, came to this thread hoping to find better signals. I didn't want to abandon my cherished system even though I never could meet Jacks criteria of averaging at least 12 points per day before risking real money. As I study Heroic's charts, labeling intently in order to keep myself...

Exactly my experience... all requirements seemed to be met, but for some reason they weren't. Too early again. Working to understand Heroic's perspective, or emphasis, along with some new vocabulary words is challenging. The truth of it seems to get clearer and clearer. I think its going to be...

Plantrader, my thoughts re the ftt surpassing p2. I know that Spydertrader didn’t require it and he had annotated charts that showed FTT not surpassing. Jack spoke against thinking vertically, but in truth I always had the same question. I’ve never seen an ftt at any fractal fail to match or...

Never mind. I wish somebody else would ask some stupid questions besides me.

just wondering - are you still all in all the time and compounding?

Using the same chain of logic described for a BBT, does FC1 set the standard for FC2? So FC2 would have to match FC1 visibly? So if FC1 is all dv bars, and FC2 is all dv bars, when FC3 bo rtl of FC2 and when FC3 (and only then) includes an iv bar, you have met requirements for a BBT?

Anyone who makes the effort to apply the logic and construct the sequences in the manner described can see that the validity of this “theory” is self-evident. In the attached snippets the volume differences are very small so I would like to know if my logic has been applied correctly, especially...

In your snippet labelled Tape Exhaustion you state “we need a failure to match or exceed volatility on tape and every smaller fractal within it…” So in my chart, if bar 1 through 4 is a complete tape, bar 4 meets that requirement. On the other hand, I think the sequence from 61 down is not a...

On 6-2, bar 4 and bar 47 don't seem to fit exhaustion requirement

Would you be willing to post your NQ chart for today? I would like to compare my annotations. Also, if 13:30 - 14:10 EST was FC 2 of BBT1 up, it seems to lack the complexity of FC 1 except for them both being complete sequences with 3 points and an ftt. Is that all that is required in terms of...

Thanks for your help and your patience. Hopefully this is a little better attempt to annotate the complete tape with the principles you have presented.

In studying 6-2 Building Tapes, I added some comments in order to clarify it for myself. Please tell me if anything is wrong.

Thank you for your help, and thanks Baro-san for the chart samples. I can see the subfractal volume sequence ending on the crest of your r2r in Baro-san ex 3. I re-taped the open of May 13 trying to look at it in a different way. I had to go back through May 12 to provide context. It still...