Mark & Magna,
do you follow the SP03 or ES03 ?
if the short entry was 90.75 with stop 2.5 away, it would be 93.25 and this is .25 above high , imo
thanks
agree, that's what I saw to. I think, nopmplease didnt take the trade, because he thought, that today will be an uptrending day.
it was at least 7 points , that he missed here, imo.
thanks to nopmplease for sharing.
no pm please
>>>This method plus my advanced one win about 70% of the time. <<<
I think, I dont understand this point. does it mean that this method plus..... or each one is winning about 70%?
what package subscribtion , did you take with esignal?
thanks for all the helpful...
baggerlord
I dont understand how one can compare jake's stoch pop and jack's rocket setup. jake is using stoch only. and thats not good enough, imo.
so try to read this thread from the beginning and then try to compare the 2 setups again.
jack's setup is much better, and much better...
dbanks
why did you post your results? do you want applause or money?
yesterday I followed your calls in indexfutures room. you forgot to call some entries and exits:confused:
and let me repeat my question from an earlier posting.
>>07/02/03 you had one trade with -3. if I understood...
dbanks
thanks for the honest answer. so nobody could take all your trades in realtime. in your monthly reports I saw a lot of +1.00 with *.
*= would have given 2 or more points.
07/02/03 you had one trade with -3. if I understood it right, you are trading with a 2 point stop. what...
dbanks
sounds very interesting:D
how do you call those trades? tradable only for you, or also tradable for the other traders, in the room that you mentioned?
thanks and best of luck
dear moderator
I am not a fan of JR's language, but nobody censored him, when he was posting in hershey's thread.
why now in his thread?
JR gave to all of us a very nice trading setup, and there is a way to ignore a poster.
I think he needs to talk like this, because his wife would...
bundlemaker
there is more than one possibility for exit. I would say, read first all hershey postings, and then start to trade.
and like Jack said -learning by doing- and a lot of washing:D
deadzone for me is 11:30 am to 02:00 pm and thats the time when volume starts to go down
Bundlemaker
Dawq explained his way, and he did quite good. dawq is using 25/75 . I still dont know what is better, 25/75 or 80/20.
hershey takes the trade immediately when both stoch lines are above/under 80/20, and MACD is =/- .40
dont forget the volume and no trades in the deadzone...
bundlemaker
take a look here
http://www.elitetrader.com/vb/showthread.php?threadid=14312
http://www.elitetrader.com/vb/showthread.php?s=&threadid=16502
hope it helps
Traduk
I trade ES 5 min chart.
thanks for your input and your last sentence, a very important point.
>>>The use of channels with failures to traverse leading to possible congestion zones or possible reversals is IMO the glue that sticks the method into a workable plan. <<<