Search results

  1. D

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    really apparent P/V and channel relationship today
  2. D

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    lol aweiss, we're in synch now (meaning you and i)
  3. D

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    here's what i came up with chart/channel aweiss your larger pink lines are sloping down, i dont' think they should be
  4. D

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    i don't think jack's method is discretionary at all, the more i delve into it. nor is it mechanical (i use discretionary/mechanical here in the most common trading sense that we're used to...trying to avoid semantics). Here's my crude analogy. I play the piano. finding sequences in the...
  5. D

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    3 questions, what is FTP, FBP and FBO? i think FBO is false break out?
  6. D

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    how's my analysis of a successful rocket vs. a failed rocket? maybe i'm getting somewhere with this... EDIT, i should add, that on the successful trade, you could have exited on the volume PEAK...that's actually a flaw in a rocket right? volume peaking= unsustainable= change upcoming...
  7. D

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    how are my chart drawing skills? i left the blue lines in there because there was some funky happenings with the traverses prior to it moving to the RTL somethine like a double FTT? i don't know, i'm just trying to get rockets to work.
  8. D

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    I saw the same things clearly today as most of you, but i couldn't execute the reversal from the failed rocket. (the initial rocket was a failure using settings of 12k vol, 80/20 stoch, +/-.4 macd, 9:30 chart start time....i think that's all the settings) ok so i washed out of the rocket...
  9. D

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    i agree aweis, i missed that one totally, stupid me thought it was 'market closed holiday'. hence didn't have my charts or anything up.
  10. D

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    rider, actually it wouldn't have killed me if i reversed after the washes...also if i did better washes. might have even made some money. chicken, you need to read more and post less. actually i found a jack quote that might address my issue, but i'm not sure....looking for comments...
  11. D

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    ah what the heck, here are my results for the last 3 days to sum up.
  12. D

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    were there any winning beginner rockets today? i had 3 losers in the es... 10:54am short @ 1191.75 (eastern time) 10:55 cov @ 1192.50 -.75 3:30pm short @ 1188.25 3:32 cov @ 1188.50 -.25 3:33 short @ 1187.50 3:35 cov @ 1188.00 -.50 (used 1 min as best...
  13. D

    30 minute bar trading using Grob/Hershey method

    after reading more of what jack has posted (and the discussions on et)...i've concluded that this is more advanced than i am currently at. so i'm stepping back to beginner stuff, just rockets. won't bother posting though, there's enough stuff on the site for the 1 out of 5 people who are...
  14. D

    30 minute bar trading using Grob/Hershey method

    picture says it all, not happy with the way i traded today. especially the amature mistake at the end. interesting to see how the projected TLs today were ALL over the place. also don't know if the double reversal projections meant anything significant. what a mess. at least i stuck...
  15. D

    Question for Grob/Hershey...

    (sorry for the intrusion guys...just looking for grob's input) ok today's results i believe i got the drawing of the composite chart down solid. i can also see the low vol/pace issue mid-day clearly. --if i sideline as volume drops into the medium/slow area, how/when do i start back up...
  16. D

    30 minute bar trading using Grob/Hershey method

    ok today's results i believe i got the drawing of the composite chart down solid. i can also see the low vol/pace issue mid-day clearly. --if i sideline as volume drops into the medium/slow area, how/when do i start back up in the fast/extra. area? keep drawing the composite chart while...
  17. D

    30 minute bar trading using Grob/Hershey method

    today i'm drawing what i believe to be the accurate charting effort per what i saw by jack....as posted in the links by mak will post the pic after the close today and the trades ...i also suspect that there's something more rewarding and imprinting about doing it by hand on a piece of...
  18. D

    30 minute bar trading using Grob/Hershey method

    actually mak, might this pic be more accurate regarding the volume/pace levels?
  19. D

    30 minute bar trading using Grob/Hershey method

    as an aside, the situations that i see this method losing money (let me rephrase that) the situations that i see this method (as i currently am employing it) losing money are in the slow pace periods like we had today and friday....and when price megaphones....larger and larger that...
  20. D

    30 minute bar trading using Grob/Hershey method

    to answer your question directly, yes there was a lot of change on friday changing lanes but not getting anywhere. my head is spinning.
Back
Top