Just closed the trade. BTC'ed the short call for $2.18, so I made a $0.54/share profit. STC'ed the long put for $0.77, so I made an $0.11/share profit.
Overall, trade profit was $0.65/share, or $260. Since I put $2000 at risk, my ROI was 13%.
I think what I should do from now on is simply...