Search results

ehorn, thanks for the spreadsheet. The spreadsheet begs a question or two, is this a 'spreadsheet exercise'? How far along are you on its actual execution? 1 month, 2 months? You 'assume' 13 points every day so it is not real experience that you can cash a check on. Have you ever traded 100...

Thank you, now we are cooking with steam!!! So if one trades all of the traverses, they are always in the market and will make 3 * H-L range net for the day. Or, should they avoid taking all of the traverses and only take the 'good' traverses that they 'want' to take? Can you always be in...

Here is a small problem that I see with your reply. I will address one at a time... 1. 'only if you want to trade all traverses' How do you know before the trade if you 'want' to trade that particular traverse? Did you 'want' to trade all of the traverses yesterday for example? Thank...

Indeed. So Romanus. Do you believe the Hershey Method: 1. Always in the market? 2. Can produce 3 * H-L 3. Can turn $10K into $15 million in one year. 4. Can keep the trader from losing trades Do you believe these core Hershey statements? Why? Please, share with us how you have...

Sightings of Bigfoot more common and better documented than SCT!!! Is the belief in SCT nothing more among cult followers than a way to "develop a sort of camaraderie — the kind of bonds that come from sitting around campfires…" Now you are talking some sense... Even they don't...

My concluding that Jack has invented something is a notion has come from Jack himself earlier today in response to the same question. Maybe you missed it: Thanks for clearing that up Spyder, I didn't think Hershey developed anything new myself.

Not pissed off at all actually. I have given you no reason to think so from my posts that I can see in re-reading my messages. Is everyone who questions the Hershey Method pissed off at something? :(

Perhaps you are right. I will ask again. Your fellow Hershey traveler, Cocaine, thinks there is nothing new in Hershey's method and that it has all been done before. Hershey said earlier today that there are "hundreds" of intellectual property and trade secrets. Have you seen just one?

Excellent point! I agree completely. So, Tums, maybe you can answer this question, "With hundreds of Hershey techniques to select from which technique would you say is the most clearly 'Hershey' in its creative implementation?" What uniquely Hershey technique has helped you make the most...

Indeed, in order to keep it simple I asked for one, "Pick one technique that you believe contributes to profitable trading..." With hundreds to select from this should be easy for you to do. Which technique would you say is the most clearly 'Hershey' in its creative implementation?

I will stand by my offer to Cocaine, "Pick out one technique that you believe contributes to your profitable trading, and I can show you a pre-dated example written in detail (with much better examples and documentation) by at least one if not many traders in the past." Jack, what part of...

Pick out one technique that you believe contributes to your profitable trading, and I can show you a pre-dated example written in detail (with much better examples and documentation) by at least one if not many traders in the past. Jack's only "genius" is in his lies and fraud. He is good at...

What you describe as 'they work' has been defined long before Hershey. Keltner, Volume Spread Analysis (well defined in Tradeguider's product), and by Richard Wyckoff. There is little disputing of the value of basic price/volume relationships. What is amazing about the cult around Jack is...

Stage 5 - Anger I took a ration of s*** from Spyder, being the "asshole", etc. With him it's always the students fault, impossible to be the teacher. You wanna explain how something as basic as picking out a FTT after the fact, by someone supposedly profitable, can be so far off base? Not a...

Hey, Trader666, bring those hershey fantasy checks over here. I think I found three guys who will cash them without any id!!!:D

It is indeed interesting, but it is called fantasy unless your banker will cash a fantasy hershey check from a fantasy hershey account. Interesting, yes. Reality, nothing to do with it...

In your experience have you known anyone, or perhaps read about anyone, who has traded at this level?

Mark in your experience have you personally known: ANYONE who traded $10k into $15 million within a year? ANYONE traded and achieved 3 * H-L profits day after day? ANYONE 'always in the market' day after day? And the list of Hershey claims is longer.... Not 'in theory or on...

Some people? 21% or 46 out of 173 Franz Shoar and MarketMonk had better numbers! And they didn't have the support of the moderators. Come on Jack, another 2000 word post or 2 before the nightcap! Work those numbers!!!!

Hi AshanD, How do you exit your trades? How to you manage risk? Can you post a screen shot? I liked Goslin book but do not remember anyone discussing it on ET before. Good trading! Looking forward to the journal!