How is that odd? If she stepped up her size, she probably wanted to focus solely on trading so she didn't make a major misstep trying to trade and post at the same time. Makes sense to me, since trading is the more important task of the two.
So it's not JUST chart based TA you have contention with, as you stated a few pages back. Got it, you've circled back to all TA now after being trapped. :)
No need to answer Surf, it was a trap anyways. Your silence on the matter speaks volumes.
I can understand not wanting to concede your entire argument against TA by admitting that past price can useful for making trades. :D
TA is more than just chart reading you know. Any analysis involving past price, as per your post recently defining TA.
Maybe he does, maybe he doesn't. Hopefully he says one way or another.