Ironically one of my most profitable trading experiences was binary options. But it was:
a) in 2005-2006.
b) Due to those options being mispriced by the broker.
As soon as situation changed, opportunity was gone, too.
Counting all days off as money lost is the shortest way to becoming a workaholic and being exposed to chronic stress. Not something recommended to anyone who wants somewhat high quality of life.
Yes I'd definitely say it is recommended to choose style with the most chances for success considering your personal traits. Including an option of not trading at all of course.