Search results

dbphoenix, Not having traded the NQ, what is the advantage of that contract over trading the ES ? (is this a pm situation...I'm new at ET) thanks, jd

I HAVE found pretty convincingly, that you cannot use the ES as your source for the TI information. It has to be the SP contract. I've tried many different incarnations of the settings and different indicators, and with the rare exception of the CCI looking at the ES, the Chaikin and the...

If I were you I wouldn't change a thing. All I needed to do was look at your profit/loss number again today to remind me of what's what. When I can do that good and show you something new, like you've been doing for us, then my comments are worth more than a hill of beans :) regards, jd

Thanks no pm. Maybe that's a good thing....that the Keltner channels don't change much during the usual timeframe of your trades. Could you somehow use that as your way of projecting your target price in advance and just walk away? If I look back over your trades with us here on the...

If you used Bolinger bands on the 5m chart it would have gotten you out around 1:45 central at 986.75. I use BBands to show me volitility. I don't see Keltner bands squeezing much as I look back at your 5m setup that I've been following with the thread. What does Keltner do for you...

Mike, I believe you need to set your session display to 630 to 115 (or whatever your time zone) so the Chaikin etc. is not starting to work from the overnight session. I believe that's what no_pm is doing. This will definitely change your indicators, at least for the ES chart. jd

MarkB, Thanks for the chart. A very clear difference between what the ES chart said and your SP chart for the Chaikin. Interestingly though, the CCI 6 and CCI 14 were both in DV at that time on my ES chart. I know that's not no_pm's system, but still worth taking a look at, for me at least...

MarkB, Could you post a chart of your trade, (good trade dude). I've only got the ES and while these no_pm setups have been pretty close, today's was not. I didn't see any DV on my 5m ES chart. Appreciate it if you have time. jd