I don't think you like being called bud. So i shall call you Dag.
Dag,
October 19th 1987 the market dropped 22% and closed at 1739, then closed the next day oct 20th at 1850.
I don't know how you do your math, Dag, but to me that's up.
If you had 1000 spy and 80 put open, and it dropped...