How about in this scenario:
Index has a 20% circuit breaker
Index is made up of sum of constituents A and B
At time T-0
A = 100, B = 200, Index = 300
You sell the same day expiration 235 P for $5 ( Just outside the 20% circuit breaker)
At time T-1
A = 70, B = 140, Index = 240 (Index has hit...