Recent content by capm

  1. C

    The “automated vs. mechanical vs. discretionary” trading debate

    Hi. Long time. Not dead yet. Here is an example of the dilemma: totally automated – semi automated systems. Here is an edited excerpt from the analysis of one my systems for the month of February. When I talk of filters I mean additional rules on the basic system’s rules. Some of them could be...
  2. C

    The “automated vs. mechanical vs. discretionary” trading debate

    Well, it did not take long for this thread to become moribund. Was it something I said? I reckon this is not exactly exciting stuff. Still, I would like to try to re-invigorate it (yes, I do not really have much of a life these days!) I will start with an example on the importance of...
  3. C

    The “automated vs. mechanical vs. discretionary” trading debate

    Thank you for your replies. @ Vtechno Thanks for reading the full post. Yes, as I did say at the beginning, this is my first experiment in a Forum and as an added experiment I thought it would be interesting to see if there are major differences between forums. This one is winning in terms of...
  4. C

    The “automated vs. mechanical vs. discretionary” trading debate

    Part 4 …and?.... Well, that’s it. That’s what I wanted to say. Ok, I guess the next question is whether I have created any system (automated or semi automated) that works. This is where I should add a picture of a young me sitting in my convertible Ferrari drinking champagne surrounded by...
  5. C

    The “automated vs. mechanical vs. discretionary” trading debate

    Part 3 More lessons So, catch 22. My next move was to see how much I could simplify, categorising my human analysis according to “degrees of programmability”, which is the inverse of “degrees of discretionary trading”. For instance, if one rule was: “do not take signals around Pivot Points”...
  6. C

    The “automated vs. mechanical vs. discretionary” trading debate

    Part 2 My journey Taking the plunge into automated systems was the start of a long journey. Soon I discovered that simply buying off the shelf automated systems would not work, for a number of reasons we may discuss in other posts. I had to develop my own systems based on some ideas that I...
  7. C

    The “automated vs. mechanical vs. discretionary” trading debate

    Part 1 Definition and characteristics So, some clarification. I would keep the trading side separate from the investing side (another long story.) I should also add that I think there is a significant division between intra – day and daily systems (ditto, perhaps another thread….) I will...
  8. C

    The “automated vs. mechanical vs. discretionary” trading debate

    Intro This is a personal experiment into the “forum” experience, induced by the “stay at home” policy. And as an experiment in the experiment, I will also post in one or more other forums (or fora, if you are a Latinist.) I do like experiments! I am so clueless regarding forum rules that I am...
Back
Top