Recent content by baggs

  1. B

    Please Critique (Poke Holes) in My Entry/Exit Strategy

    This is the "actively managed" portion of my portfolio. The rest is in passive lower "risk" assets.
  2. B

    Please Critique (Poke Holes) in My Entry/Exit Strategy

    Ugh, as I mentioned earlier, I have a lot of experience trading (6 years). I understand that psychology is more important than all else. That's a given. That's also why I'm trying to go 100% non-discretionary. ;)
  3. B

    Please Critique (Poke Holes) in My Entry/Exit Strategy

    What objective method would you choose to identify volatility? Beta, ATR, ect ...? What time frame? Or would you use something more general like VIX?
  4. B

    Please Critique (Poke Holes) in My Entry/Exit Strategy

    Thanks for the reply. The problem with this is that it's taken me a long time to build an indicator that was this "accurate" for my mid-long term style. Unfortunately, I can't simply make a few tweaks and get additional entry signals. These are the signals I have to work with and I'm trying...
  5. B

    Please Critique (Poke Holes) in My Entry/Exit Strategy

    While I very much appreciate you taking the time to respond, I don't think you read my initial post. I've been trading/investing for years. In my initial post I clearly mention what I'm trying to achieve and that all strategies "look good, until they don't". I was hoping you guys could shoot...
  6. B

    Please Critique (Poke Holes) in My Entry/Exit Strategy

    It would be interesting to see what would happen if I flipped the system and used terrible companies during downtrends.
  7. B

    Please Critique (Poke Holes) in My Entry/Exit Strategy

    I'm not saying I'll hold no matter what. I'm saying that each red line is a sell signal, that correlates with overbought and a break in uptrend. Each of those signals shows weakness. So I react by taking some profits and reducing my exposure. But if the stock continues higher, I still have money...
  8. B

    Please Critique (Poke Holes) in My Entry/Exit Strategy

    Thanks again guys for your input :) @eganon69: I will not use trendlines as I said before this needs to be 100% objective. Zero decisions made by me. It doesn't matter how many rules you create, trendlines will vary and will be nearly impossible to accurately backtest and will be subject to...
  9. B

    Please Critique (Poke Holes) in My Entry/Exit Strategy

    The profit taking signals occur when a stock is both overbought and breaking a shorter term uptrend. So the odds of getting a profit-taking signal during a drawdown is very, very small. However, these are fundamentally fantastic companies. Companies that I want to own for the mid to long term...
  10. B

    Please Critique (Poke Holes) in My Entry/Exit Strategy

    Thank you Eganon for the thoughtful reply. To clarify a few things: 1) My goal is to completely remove discretion. The entires/exits shown above are from an indicator I built. My idea was that buy and hold would be preferable, but I'd like to take some of the risk of major drawdowns off the...
  11. B

    Please Critique (Poke Holes) in My Entry/Exit Strategy

    The last 3 charts cover the 2008 fall. You'll see that in each those cases several profit taking signals were triggered before the fall. Meaning, that the initial $60,000 position (for each stock) was whittled down to very small positions when the drop came. Which is a good thing.
  12. B

    Please Critique (Poke Holes) in My Entry/Exit Strategy

    To make it easier: Green lines = $60,000 entry Red lines = $15,000 profit taking (remaining position is still being held) Generally speaking
  13. B

    Please Critique (Poke Holes) in My Entry/Exit Strategy

    Long time lurker, first time poster. Goal: 15% or greater per year (averaged over 5 years). Account Size: Approximately $900,000 (taxable acct) Timeframe: Weekly Position Strategy: Ideally 15 open positions, approx $60,000 each. I won't be going over how I decide which stocks to trade in...
Back
Top